|
|
PPCA PPCA
Legal obligation
The PPCA is a copyright collection agency that has the legal authority
to license broadcasters’ use of sound recordings protected under the
Copyright Act 1968. Previous licensing arrangements between the PPCA
and community stations came to an end some nine years ago. The fact
that during that period no community stations have had PPCA licences
means that they have been using certain sound recordings unlawfully.
In late 2001 after protracted discussions with the CBAA the PPCA made
it clear that it would pursue legal action against community stations
if they remained in breach of the law.  
From our sector’s point of view, the terms of the agreement may not be
ideal but they are the best that could be negotiated with the PPCA. In
the community broadcasting sector, the fee structure is being offered exclusively
to CBAA members. Individual agreements can be entered into with the
PPCA but they will still include the PPCA’s standard industry provisos,
will certainly attract higher fees and will not provide release from
liability for nine years of ‘back-fees’.
 
Every station must obtain a PPCA licence
The industry agreement that the CBAA signed with PPCA is not a licence
agreement and does not confer upon any station permission to broadcast
protected recordings. It recognises that the CBAA “has the right on
behalf of its members to negotiate, settle and agree with PPCA the
terms and conditions upon which the PPCA will grant radio stations a
non-exclusive licence to PPCA Sound Recordings in Australia.”  
The
industry agreement also establishes CBAA’s role in collecting fees on
behalf of our members. So if your station wants to play the
protected sound recordings covered by the PPCA, then the radio
station agreement must be completed to effect licensing. Neither the
Broadcasting Services Act nor the Copyright Act makes any legal
distinction between a permanent licensee and a temporary so all
community stations are liable.
 
PPCA does not replace APRA and AMCOSS
PPCA licences cover rights held by record companies over sound
recordings.Stations must still hold licences from the Australasian Performing
Right Association (representing songwriters, composers and publishers)
for the broadcast of musical works and the Australasian Mechanical
Copyright Owners Society controlling the reproduction rights applying
to musical works and sound recordings.
 
CBAA membership allows a concessional rate
Over several years the CBAA has pushed for a lesser financial impost
on stations than the PPCA would initially concede. The PPCA original
demand was for an annual fee of 5% of turnover and it has taken
considerable effort and negotiation to push it back to 0.4%. After
consideration and approval by the CBAA’s National Committee, the CBAA
entered into an industry agreement with the PPCA on the 29th of
November 2001 which provides for the CBAA to undertake the
administrative burden of fee collection and ‘locks-in’ a uniform, low
rate for annual fees (0.4% with a minimum of $250).  
Unlike, say, the APRA agreement, fees are not adjusted on music usage.
But the agreement does establish a concessional levy over three years
in consideration of what would have otherwise amounted to nine years
in back-fees. All monies collected will be remitted to the PPCA without
any levy or commission for the CBAA.
 
Annual fee invoiced each July
The fee payable in 2001/2002 has been based on gross revenue for the
1999/2000 period. The initial invoice is effectively six months
behind schedule. The fee for the next year falls due in July 2002 and will be based on 2000/2001 and so on. There is a drafting error in the agreement with the periods for assessment of fees a year out of sync. PPCA has been alerted and will make an amendment.
 
Minimum fee (see "1.Interpretation")
There has been a degree of concern about the minimum fee in proportional
terms for stations with low turnover. The PPCA has set this minimum rate in consideration of what it believes is acceptable and affordable in dollar terms. The CBAA was successful in negotiating it down from $500. Bear in mind that prior to 1993 each and every station regardless of size paid the PPCA a flat $300 annual fee, which in those times was a more severe impost.
 
The 7 week rule (clause 3.1 (a))
Stations are not allowed to reproduce or broadcast any PPCA sound
recording before it has been published in Australia or before 7 weeks
have elapsed and this has raised the hackles of some of our members.
This obligation is not created by the agreement between the CBAA and PPCA - it is a
standard term which applies to all broadcasters - whether commercial, community or
narrowcaster. It is an obligation created by the Copyright Act (section 109) and Regulations - and the inclusion of this term in the contract is just an important reminder of a statutory obligation.
 
Logging (3.1(d)& (e))
Music logging is essential to the fair disbursement by collection agencies of
royalties to rights holders. Across the whole broadcasting industry music logging
is an established practice. Neither the PPCA nor the CBAA want to see any
additional resource burden imposed on community stations in this regard so it was
agreed that rather than ‘reinvent the wheel’ stations should provide
copies of
logs already produced for APRA’s purposes.   APRA logs a
select sample of stations
four times a year for a period of one week. If your stations does not currently
supply logs to APRA it will only need to supply logs to PPCA “at times specified by
the PPCA”. There are no immediate plans to require stations that are not being
logged by APRA to supply logs just for the PPCA’s purposes although it is their
legal right to require them.
 
Ban on continuous playing of artist or album (3.1 (g))
The CBAA had argued strongly against this requirement on the grounds that it would
impede the capacity of stations to feature artists or albums in special programs.
The PPCA was not prepared to compromise on this point
saying that the requirement to play no more than four tracks from the
same album or artist without a break of fifteen minutes between the
third and fourth track is a standard provision of agreements
throughout the broadcasting industry.  
Its policy intention is prevent the continuous playing out of an entire
CD to prevent off-air recording of sound recordings. In practical terms
there is little likelihood of the PPCA policing the duration of the break.
After being approached by the fine music stations the PPCA has said that
will entertain making exemptions to this rule for the broadcast of operatic
or symphonic works.
 
PPCA rights of entry, examination and audit
The PPCA is lawfully entitled to enter into an agreement which secures
access to premises and company/association records for legitimate
business purposes. In any case, a requirement of CBAA membership is that
stations provide audited financial statements to us each year. Because the
CBAA has undertaken to calculate fees based on these statements and collect
payments, the prospect of PPCA entering premises and making copies of accounts
would only ever transpire if a station refused to divulge its true financial
position or attempted to withhold financial reports.
 
Compliance is advisable
The CBAA has diligently represented the interests of community
broadcasters in all dealings with the PPCA and striven to negate
unnecessary or onerous contractual stipulations. The CBAA has
entered an industry agreement which maximises the benefits for our
member stations collectively but will entail a degree of compromise
for some stations.
If issues arise, the CBAA will continue to represent its members and
take all reasonable steps to dissuade the PPCA from pursuing
unnecessary or punitive legal action against members.   However the
PPCA has strongly expressed its preparedness to take legal action
against stations who use protected sound recordings without a licence.
It would not be in the interests of our membership for the CBAA to
endorse any station’s refusal to enter into a licence agreement and
we do not recommend that stations continue to use protected sound
recordings without a licence.
None of this is all that welcome, I guess to our largely volunteer
sector which is struggling with limited resources and tight budgets.
  If the CBAA can be of any assistance please contact:
  Cameron Woods on:
(02) 9318 9606 or cwoods@cbaa.org.au
|
|
|